Why do we need a separate Medicare levy in Australia? It all goes into the same pool of funds anyway. So why bother?
We had assumed that the Medicare levy goes into a separate pool. But then we read Bob Deutsch’s preamble in Tax Vine – the monthly newsletter by The Tax Institute – and learned that it doesn’t.
In this episode Bob Deutsch, the Senior Tax Counsel of The Tax Institute, will elaborate on all this. Here is what we learned.
Segregating the Medicare levy from income tax is misleading. It gives the impression that there is a separate pool of funds that is available for the federal government to finance Medicare. But there is no separate pool.
Calculating the Medicare levy separately from income tax fundamentally adds to the complexity of the Australian tax system. We impose different criteria in respect of its application with different brackets and exemptions. All this makes it a lot more complicated, but for what? It all goes into the same pot after all.
We would simplify our tax system significantly if we completely abolished the Medicare levy. Just having one overall income tax would make things a lot simpler.
Medicare Levy Surcharge
The Medicare Levy Surcharge is to incentivise higher paid individuals to take up private health insurance. But we should still consider moving it into the overall income tax charge. Our tax system would become so much more straight forward.
All this would result in a much more open and honest approach. We would then finally concede that our real top marginal tax rate is 47% not 45%. And it would show that the opposition’s proposed real top tax rate would be 49% rather than 47%. In addition, we would simplify the system.
So this is our take-away from this episode. But please listen to the actual interview. Bob outlines his thinking much better than we ever could.
Disclaimer: Tax Talks does not provide financial or tax advice. This applies to these show notes as well as the actual podcast interview. All information on Tax Talks is provided for entertainment purposes only and might no longer be up to date or correct. You should seek professional accredited tax and financial advice when considering whether the information is suitable to your or your client’s circumstances.
Last Updated on 22 May 2019